Denial Management for Small Practices: A Simple Weekly Routine
Denial management is the work of finding, fixing and preventing denied insurance claims. In a small practice, it usually means one or two people working through a stack of denials between other jobs. This guide gives you a simple weekly routine you can run with the staff you already have.
Why denials deserve a routine
Denials are not a small leak. In a January 2026 MGMA poll of medical practice leaders, 48% named denials and appeals as the biggest revenue leak in their practice, well ahead of front-end issues at 23% and coding at 13% (MGMA Stat, January 2026). In a 2026 Experian Health survey of healthcare billing and finance staff, 75% agreed that claim denials are increasing (Experian Health, October 2026).
The cost of not working denials is real. A peer-reviewed study of physician billing found that doctors lose an estimated 18% of Medicaid revenue to billing problems, compared with 4.7% for Medicare and 2.4% for commercial insurers (NBER Working Paper 29010, data from 2013 to 2015). Those figures include both the cost of rework and the money never collected.
The good news: a short, steady routine catches most of what slips through.
Step 1: Pull every denial into one list
Each week, pull every denied and unpaid claim into one list. Start from your electronic remittance advice (the payment files your clearinghouse receives from payers, often called 835 files) and your accounts receivable aging report.
For each claim, record:
- Payer
- Date of service
- Dollar amount
- Denial reason code and plain-language reason
- Date the denial was received
- Appeal or resubmission deadline
One list is the most important step. Denials hidden in separate portals and mail piles are the ones that get written off.
Step 2: Sort by deadline, then by dollars
Work the claims with the nearest deadline first. Medicare, for example, requires a fee-for-service claim to be filed within 1 calendar year after the date of service (42 CFR 424.44), and a redetermination request must be filed within 120 days of getting the remittance advice (CMS, MLN006562). Commercial payer deadlines are set in each payer contract, so keep a short table of your top payers' limits.
After deadlines, sort by dollar amount. A single high-dollar denial is often worth more than ten small ones.
Step 3: Group by reason
Group the list by denial reason. Most denials fall into a few buckets:
- Front-end errors: wrong patient ID, eligibility, missing information.
- Coverage: service not covered or not medically necessary.
- Authorization: prior authorization missing or denied.
- Coding: wrong code, missing or wrong modifier, bundling.
- Timely filing: filed too late.
Each bucket has its own fix. Front-end errors usually need a corrected claim. Coverage and medical necessity denials usually need an appeal with records. Timely filing denials are often final. See our guide to top claim denial reasons.
Step 4: Fix, resubmit or appeal
For each claim, choose one of three actions:
- Correct and resubmit when the denial came from a data or coding error.
- Appeal when you believe the payer was wrong. See our guide on how to appeal a denied claim.
- Write off only when the claim truly cannot be paid, and record why.
Appeals are often worth filing. In Medicare Advantage, only 11.5% of denied prior authorization requests were appealed in 2024, but 80.7% of those appeals were partly or fully overturned (KFF, January 2026). That is prior authorization data, not all claims, but it shows how much money can sit in denials nobody challenges.
Step 5: Track follow-up
A resubmitted claim or an appeal is not done until it is paid or formally closed. Add a follow-up date to every claim you work. If a payer has not answered by that date, check status in the portal or call.
Step 6: Review the numbers once a month
Once a month, look at three numbers:
- Denial rate: denied claims divided by claims submitted, times 100. See our post on claim denial rate benchmarks.
- Top 3 denial reasons: these tell you what to fix at the front desk or in coding.
- Dollars written off: this is the money you chose not to chase.
Share the top reasons with the front desk and coders. Prevention is cheaper than rework.
A sample weekly schedule
| Day | Task | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Monday | Pull new denials into the list | 30 to 60 minutes |
| Tuesday to Thursday | Fix, resubmit and appeal, nearest deadline first | 1 to 2 hours a day |
| Friday | Follow up on open claims and update the list | 1 hour |
The times above are a starting guide, not a benchmark. Adjust them to your volume.
Where small practices get stuck
The routine is simple. Keeping it going is hard. Denials arrive every day, staff get pulled to the front desk, and hold times with payers eat whole afternoons. That is when claims slip past their deadlines.
Get early access to Eligra
Eligra is building a denial recovery tool for small practices. It will sort every denied and unpaid claim, draft the fix for your team to approve, and follow up until each one is closed. Join the waitlist for early access.
Sources
- MGMA Stat, "Detecting and fixing leaks across the revenue cycle," January 7, 2026: https://www.mgma.com/mgma-stat/detecting-and-fixing-leaks-across-the-revenue-cycle
- Experian Health, "Healthcare claim denial statistics: State of Claims Report 2026," October 28, 2026: https://www.experian.com/blogs/healthcare/healthcare-claim-denials-statistics-state-of-claims-report/
- Dunn and others, "A Denial a Day Keeps the Doctor Away," NBER Working Paper 29010: https://www.nber.org/papers/w29010
- 42 CFR 424.44: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-424/subpart-C/section-424.44
- CMS, "Medicare Parts A & B Appeals Process," MLN006562, September 2025: https://www.cms.gov/files/document/mln006562-medicare-parts-b-appeals-process.pdf
- KFF, Medicare Advantage prior authorization in 2024, January 28, 2026: https://www.kff.org/medicare/medicare-advantage-insurers-made-nearly-53-million-prior-authorization-determinations-in-2024/