What Is a Normal Claim Denial Rate? Benchmarks for Small Practices

By Eligra · · 4 min read

A claim denial rate is the share of claims a payer denies out of all the claims you submit. It is one of the simplest numbers to track, and one of the most useful. This guide explains how to calculate it and what recent benchmarks say.

How to calculate your denial rate

Denial rate = denied claims ÷ claims submitted × 100, for the same period.

Example: your practice submitted 500 claims in October and 40 were denied on first submission. 40 ÷ 500 × 100 = 8%.

Track it three ways:

  1. By count: the share of claims denied.
  2. By dollars: denied dollars divided by billed dollars. A low count rate can hide a few large denials.
  3. By payer: one payer with a high rate is easier to fix than a general problem.

Use the first-submission rate (also called the initial denial rate) as your main number. It shows how clean your claims are before any rework.

What the benchmarks say

Benchmarks vary by source, by setting and by method. Here are the most useful recent figures:

Source Finding Who it covers
MGMA, 2023 data 8% of claims denied on first submission, the same rate as in 2019 Single-specialty medical practices
Kodiak Solutions, cited by HFMA 11.65% initial denial rate in 2025 through November, up from 11.41% in 2024 Hospitals and physicians
Experian Health, 2026 40% of respondents say at least 1 in 10 claims is denied; 14% say more than 15% 204 billing and finance staff at provider organizations
Peer-reviewed study, 2013 to 2015 data 7% of physician visits had at least one denied line item 81.4 million physician visits

Sources: MGMA Stat (March 2024); HFMA (January 2026); Experian Health (October 2026); Dunn and others, "A Denial a Day Keeps the Doctor Away" (2023).

So what is a "good" denial rate?

There is no single official target. Based on the figures above:

  • About 8% or lower on first submission is in line with MGMA's figure for single-specialty practices.
  • Above 10% puts you among the 40% of Experian survey respondents who report at least 1 in 10 claims denied.
  • Above 15% is high in that survey: only 14% of respondents reported it.

These are reference points, not rules. A practice with many Medicaid patients may see higher rates than a practice with mostly commercial patients. In the peer-reviewed study, 24% of Medicaid claims had at least one service denied on first submission, compared with 6.7% for Medicare and 4.1% for commercial insurance (Dunn and others, data from 2013 to 2015).

Denial rates are rising

Several sources point the same way:

  • 75% of Experian survey respondents agreed that claim denials are increasing (Experian Health, 2026).
  • 60% of medical group leaders in a March 2024 MGMA poll said their denial rates had risen compared with the year before (MGMA Stat, March 2024).
  • Kodiak's initial denial rate rose from 11.41% in 2024 to 11.65% in 2025 through November (HFMA, January 2026).

The number that matters more: what you recover

A denial rate shows how many claims come back. It does not show how many you recover. In the Experian survey, 86% of respondents said they successfully resubmit denied claims at least half the time, but only 30% said they recover 80% to 100% of denied revenue, and 52% said they recover only 50% to 70% (Medical Economics, October 2026, reporting Experian's survey).

So track two more numbers each month:

  1. Denials worked: the share of denied claims your team corrected, resubmitted or appealed.
  2. Dollars recovered: money collected on denied claims, divided by denied dollars.

A practice with a 10% denial rate that works every denial can do better than a practice with a 6% rate that writes most of them off.

How to lower your denial rate

  1. Find your top 3 denial reasons each quarter. See top claim denial reasons.
  2. Fix the step that causes each one, often eligibility checks or coding.
  3. Work every denial before its deadline. See timely filing limits and how to appeal a denied claim.
  4. Review the numbers monthly with your billing team.

Get early access to Eligra

Eligra is building a denial recovery tool that shows your denial rate, top reasons and dollars at stake in one view, and helps your team work every denial. Join the waitlist for early access.

Sources