The Top Reasons Medical Claims Get Denied, and How to Prevent Them

By Eligra · · 4 min read

A claim denial is a payer's decision not to pay a claim, in full or in part. Some denials come from errors your practice can prevent. Others come from payer rules and need an appeal. Knowing which is which is the first step to getting paid.

What the data says in 2026

In the 2026 Experian Health State of Claims survey of 204 healthcare billing, finance and claims staff, the most common denial reasons were (Experian Health, October 2026):

  • Services not covered: a top-three reason for 53% of respondents.
  • Frequently changing payer policies: 31%.
  • Code inaccuracy errors: 25%.
  • Difficulty obtaining prior authorization: 25%.

The same survey found that 40% of respondents say at least 1 in 10 of their claims is denied.

Physician practices report a similar picture. In a March 2024 MGMA poll, practice leaders whose denials rose or held steady said their recent denials centered on insufficient documentation, patient eligibility or incorrect ID numbers, untimely filing, and incorrect modifier use, especially modifier 25 (MGMA Stat, March 2024). In MGMA's January 2026 poll, leaders described denial losses as centering on medical necessity, non-covered services, and bundling and global package edits (MGMA Stat, January 2026).

The six most common denial reasons

1. Service not covered

The payer says the plan does not cover the service. Sometimes this is true. Often the issue is a missing diagnosis that supports coverage, or a plan policy the practice did not know about.

Prevent it: Check coverage for planned services before the visit. Keep a short list of services your top payers often deny.

2. Eligibility and patient information errors

Wrong member ID, inactive coverage, wrong date of birth or the wrong payer listed as primary.

Prevent it: Verify eligibility before every visit, not only at the first visit. Scan the front and back of the insurance card each time it changes.

3. Missing or denied prior authorization

The service needed approval before it was done, and approval was missing, expired or did not match the service billed.

Prevent it: Keep a list of services that need prior authorization for each major payer. Match the authorization number, dates and codes to the claim before you submit it.

4. Coding and modifier errors

The procedure code, diagnosis code or modifier is wrong or missing. Modifier 25 errors were named often in the MGMA poll.

Prevent it: Review the top denied codes each month with your coder. Fix the template or charge entry step that causes the error.

5. Insufficient documentation or medical necessity

The payer wants records that show why the service was needed.

Prevent it: Make sure the note supports the codes billed. When a denial comes in, send the records the payer asks for, with a short letter that points to the key facts.

6. Timely filing

The claim reached the payer after the filing deadline. Medicare requires fee-for-service claims within 1 calendar year after the date of service (42 CFR 424.44). CMS treats a late-filing denial as not open to appeal (CMS guidance, 2006). See our guide to timely filing limits.

Prevent it: Work rejections from your clearinghouse every day, so a rejected claim does not sit until the deadline passes.

Fix or appeal? A quick guide

Denial reason Usual next step
Eligibility or patient data error Correct and resubmit
Coding or modifier error Correct and resubmit
Missing prior authorization Ask the payer about retro authorization, or appeal
Not covered or not medically necessary Appeal with records
Timely filing Usually final; check for a valid exception
Duplicate claim Check if the first claim was paid

How to find your own top reasons

Your top denial reasons may differ from the national lists. To find them:

  1. Export the last 90 days of denials from your remittance files or practice management system.
  2. Group them by reason code.
  3. Rank the groups by count and by dollars.
  4. Pick the top 3 and fix the step that causes each one.

Repeat every quarter. Payer policies change often: 31% of respondents in the Experian survey named changing policies as a top reason.

Prevention is only half the job

Even a careful practice gets denials, because many are payer driven. The money is in working the denials that do come in, quickly and before deadlines. See denial management for small practices for a simple weekly routine.

Get early access to Eligra

Eligra is building a denial recovery tool that groups every denial by reason and dollars, and drafts the fix for your team to approve. Join the waitlist for early access.

Sources